Family Stories

McKinley Family Buried at Bells Run Baptist Cemetery – Ohio County

Today we visit Bells Run Baptist Church, in the small area of the same name.  Bells Run is located in the north-western section of the Ohio County, at the intersections of Hwys 764 and 762.  This is a beautiful cemetery, alongside a handsome church.  Our focus will be on the McKinley family.

Isaac N. McKinley, August 29, 1858 – June 15, 1946.  Lout. Ann, August 1, 1866 – January 8, 1924.  Bells Run Baptist Cemetery, Ohio County, Kentucky.

My interest in this family began with Isaac N. McKinley and Lou T. McKinley.  A quick census search found them in Ohio County in 1900, both aged 32.  They had been married ten years, had four children, three living – Ernest, 5; Armit, 4; and Mamie, 2.  By 1910 the youngest child had died; two new babies were born – Mary, 10; and Augusta, 4.  According to the 1905 Owensboro Directory, Davis County, the family had moved from their Ohio County home.  Owensboro is just 15 miles from Bells Run, it isn’t as far away as it might sound.  Lou died in 1924, and Isaac married Martha J. Quick.

Messenger Inquirer, Owensboro, Daviess County, Kentucky

Thursday, February 28, 1924

Messenger Inquirer, Owensboro, Daviess County, Kentucky

Sunday, June 16, 1946

Ben P. McKinley, 1865-1939.  Alice McKinley, 1865-1949.

Buried next to Isaac and Lou were his brother Benjamin Proctor McKinley and his wife, Sarah Alice Stinnett.  They were married in 1890.

The Courier-Journal, Louisville, Jefferson County, Kentucky

Wednesday, February 22, 1939

Messenger Inquirer, Owensboro, Daviess County, Kentucky

Sunday, July 31, 1949

Ruse McKinley, 1875-1895.  Ida McKinley, 1876-1967.

Close by another brother and his wife are buried – Rousseau S. McKinley and Ida Taylor McKinley.  Notice the early death of Ruse – barely twenty years.  One son, Charles Rousseau, was born September 29, 1894.  Ruse did not live to see his son’s first birthday. There was no obituary for him.  Remarkably, even though widowed at a very young age, Ida raised her son, saw grandchildren born and her son die before she passed away November 10, 1967, at the advanced age of 91.

Messenger-Inquirer, Owensboro, Daviess County, Kentucky

Monday, December 11, 1967

Charles McKinley, born September 29, 1894 – September 12 1963.  Ina B. Patton McKinley, December 1, 1892 – February 1, 1934.

Ruse and Ida’s son Charles married Ina B.Patton.

Messenger Inquirer, Owensboro, Daviess County, Kentucky

Thursday, September 12, 1963

Isaac, Ben and Ruse were sons of Joseph McKinley and Cynthia Sharp.  The couple’s marriage bond was dated May 9, 1864.  By 1870 they were 27 and 23, respectively, with children Samuel F, 5; Ben, 3; and Isaac N., 10/12.  Ten years later three more children were added to the family list – Ira P., 7; Ruse, 4; and Della, 2.  Cynthia died in 1890, and Joseph married Susan Chapman the next year.

Joseph McKinley, July 11, 1844 – July 17, 1918.  Cynthia

Could we possibly go back further?  Joseph McKinley died in 1918, when death certificates were required.  His parents are listed as Benjamin McKinley and ? Bozarth.  Let’s check an earlier census record.

Ohio County, I do certify that on the 20 day of April 1842, I joined Benjamin McKinley and Charlotte Bozarth in wedlock.  Joseph Mill, MMEC.

In the 1850 census for Ohio County Benjamin McKinley, 45, born in Virginia, was listed with wife Charlotte, 30, and children Joseph, 6; Alexander, 5; Margaret E., 3; Rachel C., 1; and his mother, Henrietta McKinley, 85, born in Virginia.  Two more generations.  And his mother was born about 1765!  Benjamin McKinley married Charlotte Bozarth April 20, 1842.

By 1860 the family is fractured.  Benjamin McKinley is not listed in the census; neither is Charlotte.  I found Joseph, 16, and brother Alexander, 15, living as ‘boarder and farmer’ with Moses Spencer.  Daughter Rachel C. McKinley, now 11, is living with William T. Sharp and family.  William is 51, with wife Susan, 35, (second wife, not the mother of the children), Cynthia M. 14 (recognize this name from above?  Another generation!); Thomas, 12; Joshua, 6; step-children John Simmons, 15; Jesse, 13; and Hiram, 11; Rachel C. McKinley, 11, a boarder; and Isaac Sharp, laborer.  Rachel McKinley boards with the family that her brother Joseph later marries into.

Ohio County, This is to certify that Moses Spencer was married to Mrs. Charlotte McKinley on the third day of May 1855.  James C. Stewart, MG.

And Moses Spencer?  After the death of Benjamin McKinley, wife Charlotte marries Moses Spencer May 3, 1855.

Research for this family was exciting – starting with five gravestones we found census records, death certificates, marriage certificates, obituaries – all original, public records to find our families and make our connections.

Any thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s